On “Saturday Night Live,” a pre-recorded segment called “Sister” hit too close to home for some, and others say the segment helped them finally feel seen. In the sketch, comedian John Mulaney pitches a care system for elderly parents that offers a live-in 24-hour caregiver that can be activated instantly with a simple text, “dad fell.” It’s called Sister. One message, and your actual sister will “quit her job, break her lease, and move halfway across the country to take care of him,” all for free. “Years of internalized sexism warp sister’s brain into thinking caretaking is her responsibility and somehow not yours,” a doctor, played by Mikey Day, explains. “Next, your text arrives, instantly activating her and that’s it, you’re done for life. See you at the funeral.” Millions have watched the YouTube clip, and it’s lighting up caregiver forums nationwide. As soon as the segment aired, Dr. Donna Benton, director of the USC Family Caregiver Support Center, said she was flooded with emails and texts. “It hit a nerve, obviously, with many, many women. And my whole reaction is ‘Yeah, I’ve been saying this for how long?’” Her research characterizing caregiving in California over the last several decades shows a 70-30 split, with women handling most of the caregiving. “That hasn’t changed in the 40 years,” Benton said. But the good thing about the SNL sketch, she said, is that it prompted people who saw it to reach out “saying ‘What can we do? How can we address this?’” “If this starts a new national conversation, that will be a success.” Your caregiving future There’s a good chance you will end up caring for an aging parent at some point, especially if you are a woman. Most older people with long-term care needs in the United States rely exclusively on family and friends to help them. “We think the way our parents were in their 50s and 60s will continue forever. But when you cross that 80-year-old mark, most older adults are going to need help,” Benton said. Nearly one in five adults — 51 million Americans — are caregivers for loved ones 50 and older. Three in five family caregivers are women, according to AARP research. “The female caregiver, the sister, the daughter, the cousin, the neighbour are stepping in to fill the gaps in what is a national care crisis,” said Jason Resendez, president and CEO of the National Alliance for Caregiving, a research and policy group. This phenomenon is so common that it has even earned a nickname: “the daughter tax.” Caregiving often begins with what experts call “caregiver creep.” Adult children run errands for their parents at first, but as their parent becomes frailer, the children step in to take on more. Even if there are multiple children in the family, it’s typically a sister, not a brother, who shoulders the bulk of the caregiving. An influential 2017 study quantified the time daughters versus sons spend on care and found daughters spend more than twice as much time caring for their aging parents as sons do. On average, daughters logged 12.3 hours of care each month, compared with just 5.6 hours for sons. “It’s hardly surprising to say that women provide more care,” said study co-author Dr. Angelina Grigoryeva, an assistant professor in the sociology department at the University of Toronto. It’s mostly women who oversee a parent’s medication, drive them to the doctor, prepare meals, clean homes, battle insurance companies and do everything they can to keep their parents physically safe. And, studies show, most do it without formal or financial support, often at such a great cost to themselves physically, emotionally and financially that researchers call caregivers “invisible second patients.” “Caregiving is not an easy task. It is one thing to give a baby a bath, imagine having to give a bath to an adult person,” Grigoryeva said. “It’s also more stressful. And many American women have to provide childcare and elder care at the same time, and it all comes at a cost.” While societal expectations are that women are the more nurturing gender, much of elderly parent caregiving is learned on the fly with no real time for trial and error. “It can start with a call from your mom that she fell, so it’s hard to prepare for this until you’re really in the thick of it,” said Debra Whitman, chief public policy officer at AARP. And the caregiving role can last decades. Toll of caregiving Often, the physical impact of caregiving hits women harder than men. Nearly 40 per cent of women who are caregivers say that caregiving has taken a negative toll on their physical health, compared with 26 per cent of men. It also strains women’s mental health, with 47 per cent of women saying caring for an aging parent has weighed on their emotional well-being. There is no federal paid family leave and no job protection for people who step away to care for an aging parent. While 44 per cent of people who are caregivers work full-time, sometimes an aging parent’s needs become so great that caregivers leave the workforce, move to part-time work or retire early. “If you have to take time off of work, you also lose your health benefits, you lose access to retirement savings or pensions, and you later take a hit on your Social Security,” said Whitman. She noted that altogether, an average working caregiver forfeits about US$120,500 in wages, retirement savings and Social Security. If a caregiver can work, they will often settle for a more flexible position that pays less or comes with a less desirable shift. Even when they return to work after an elderly parent dies, caregivers are much more likely to earn lower wages, land a “benefit-poor” job and receive reduced retirement benefits, research shows. The person who provides care for their parent also bears the most out-of-pocket expenses, and those expenses have climbed sharply. AARP estimates family caregivers spend an average of US$11,508 a year out of pocket, almost 60 per cent more than they did in 2021. Caregivers of a parent with Alzheimer’s or another form of dementia shell out even more, with an average of US$15,846 a year. In total, family caregivers devote 31 per cent of their household income to caregiving expenses, according to an October AARP research report. AARP has been urging Congress to offer tax credits for these out-of-pocket expenses. ‘Speak to human. Speak to human.’ Benton also points to the added emotional labour highlighted in the SNL sketch. Mulaney explains that Sister will talk to doctors on the phone, talk to insurance companies on the phone and talk to pharmacists on the phone. “Speak to human, speak to human,” the sister says into her speakerphone. Benton said that exchange shows the caregiving problem is not just about unequal gender roles; it also underscores how much systems-level change is needed. “Systems have pushed us where we can’t even talk to a person. You have to make three phone calls and navigate this very complex healthcare system and it’s very frustrating,” Benton said. Benton said social service systems are dramatically underfunded. And many don’t realize Medicare does not pay for long-term or nursing home care that would help with daily activities like bathing, dressing or eating. “We don’t have a good national long-term strategy for caregiving and that puts more pressures back on the families and on women in particular,” Benton said. “Systems aren’t helping us as caregivers. It’s actually making it harder.” Caregiving conversations to start now What can help as parents age, AARP’s Whitman said, is to hold an open conversation before the need arises about what should happen if a parent requires help. “Communication is really important, and so is dividing up responsibilities,” she said. It’s also important to make room for the caregiver to ask for help. A shared calendar to manage tasks can help, and it’s important to frame caregiving as a team activity. It’s easier to get people to step up when using words “we” and “together” instead of saying “you.” It’s also important to ask for help before a caregiver feels overwhelmed. Reaching out is not a sign of weakness. Ultimately, though, Benton believes a broader conversation is needed about systems outside the home, and the belief that women have to do it all. “Because I tend to think that the systems have to change because these systems impact women in a different way that it does men,” Benton said. That sense that women think they are the ones who have to take on the caregiver role, even if it hurts them personally, doesn’t happen organically. “Part of the internalized expectations comes from the fact that we don’t have external options,” Benton said. Benton asks why caregiving can’t generate a certain amount of credits for Social Security, or why there aren’t tax breaks for people who have to take time off to provide elder or child care. “With our aging population, we are going to have more older adults than younger children,” she said. “So elder care is going to be even more of the norm in the next 10 years and this system we have now is not sustainable long-term.” By Jen Christensen, CNN Saturday Night Live airs live in Canada on CTV and streams live on Crave, with next-day on-demand streaming on Crave.