A B.C. Realtor has been ordered to pay more than $50,000 over a conflict of interest he says he entered to help his client. The B.C. Financial Services Authority ordered Inderjit Arora and his personal real estate corporation to pay an administrative penalty and enforcement expenses in a decision issued back in February, which was not published on the regulator’s website until last week. The document indicates that Arora submitted a $1.8-million offer for a Surrey property on behalf of his client in late January of 2021. Under the terms of the purchase and sale agreement, the buyer paid an initial deposit of $150,000 in early February of that year, and there was a second deposit of $50,000 due in early June. When the time came to pay that deposit, however, the buyer was unable to do so, according to the decision. Instead, a member of Arora’s family wrote a cheque for the amount, which Arora delivered to the sellers. Arora then entered an agreement with the buyer—a close personal friend—to assign the contract of purchase and sale to himself. The decision indicates he reported to his brokerage that he would receive no compensation for the assignment sale, but he ultimately received more than $28,000 in commission from the sellers, who didn’t learn until closing that Arora, rather than his client, was the buyer. Arora and his family member took possession of the home in September 2021, and it has been used as a rental property for at least some of the time since then, according to the decision. When the seller filed a complaint about the transaction and the BCFSA contacted Arora, he explained that he agreed to be assigned the contract so that his client wouldn’t lose her initial deposit due to financing issues. Arora told the regulator there was no written agreement between the parties for when or how the original buyer would get her deposit back, but that a “bare trust agreement” had been proposed. The intention, according to the decision, is for the client to get her deposit back “if there is a profit in the future” when the property is sold again. The Realtor also maintained that there was no conflict of interest in the case, because neither he nor his corporation became a creditor of the client. The $50,000 was not a loan, but a gift, he argued, and it came from his family member, not himself. BCFSA hearing officer Andrew Pendray disagreed with this argument, noting in his decision that the arrangement inherently placed the parties at odds with each other, in breach of Arora’s duty as a Realtor to always act in his client’s best interests. Once Arora took on the assignment, Pendray noted, his client’s best interests could be seen as having her $150,000 deposit paid back “quickly and with interest,” while his interest as the new owner of the property would be to delay and reduce such a payment. “Simply put, even if Mr. Arora were to in fact act in (the buyer)’s interests and contrary to his own, their interests can properly be seen to have been in conflict at the time the assignment was entered into,” Pendray’s decision reads. “While I accept the evidence and information before me indicating that the parties have long been friends, this was the type of transaction where the interests of the individuals involved, regardless of friendship, may collide.” The hearing officer concluded based on the agreed facts in the case that Arora had committed professional misconduct by failing to take reasonable steps to avoid a conflict of interest, failing to act with reasonable care and skill, failing to disclose the source of his remuneration and failing to disclose to the sellers that he would be acquiring the property. While he found some of Arora’s misconduct to be “minor,” Pendray concluded that some aspects of it were serious. He ruled that there was a need for a monetary penalty “of some significance” to deter Arora and others from repeating the misconduct, and to maintain public confidence in the industry. Pendray ultimately ordered Arora and his corporation to jointly pay a $50,000 penalty, plus $8,908 in enforcement expenses, within 60 days.